The Osage Murders, a series of chilling and calculated killings in the 1920s, represent a significant yet often overlooked chapter in American history. This series of events not only highlights the exploitation and injustice faced by the Osage Nation but also played a pivotal role in the evolution of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).
Background:
The Osage Nation and Oil Wealth
- The Discovery of Oil: In the early 20th century, the Osage Nation in Oklahoma found themselves sitting atop vast oil reserves. This discovery transformed the Osage into some of the wealthiest people per capita in the world.
- Headrights System: The wealth was distributed through a system of headrights, which granted members of the Osage Nation shares of the oil revenue.
The Reign of Terror: The Osage Murders
- A Series of Mysterious Deaths: Beginning in the early 1920s, members of the Osage Nation began dying under mysterious circumstances. These deaths, often violent, seemed to target those with substantial headrights.
Mollie (right) with her sisters Anna (center) and Minnie.
Photograph courtesy Doubleday
- Key Victims: Among the most notable victims were members of the family of Mollie Burkhart, an Osage woman whose relatives were systematically murdered.
- Anna Brown (1921): One of the first victims, found shot dead. Her murder remained unsolved initially. On May 21, 1923, following her sister Mollie's request, Anna traveled to Gray Horse to care for their ailing mother. Unfortunately, Anna was inebriated from illicit whiskey, leading to complications. Once she regained some sobriety and ate something, Bryan Burkhart, Mollie's brother-in-law's sibling, offered Anna a ride home. Anna bid farewell to Mollie, a farewell that would be their last. A week later, a boy hunting squirrels near Fairfax discovered a decomposing body in a ravine, identifiable as Anna Brown by the gold dental fillings and a blanket. Drs. James and David Shoun conducted an autopsy, concluding that Anna had been deceased for about a week, victim to a .32-caliber gunshot to the head.
---
- Bill Smith and Rita Smith (1922): Their home was bombed, killing both. On March 9, after following up on a clue related to Roan's homicide with a companion, Bill Smith returned to his Fairfax residence in his Studebaker. His spouse, Rita, was there to greet him. Nettie Brookshire, a young employee of the Smith family, was also staying over that night. At 2:50 AM, a massive explosion devastated the Smith home. Rita and Nettie were killed instantly, while Bill, severely burned and barely recognizable, astonishingly survived for a few days. As he lingered on the brink of death, Bill would often exclaim in despair, "They took Rita, and it seems they've taken me too."
- Growing Concerns: As the death toll rose, the Osage Nation requested help, suspecting these were not isolated incidents but part of a larger conspiracy.
Investigation Challenges
- Local Law Enforcement: Initially, local law enforcement and private detectives struggled to solve the crimes, with corruption and incompetence hindering the investigations.
- Growing Public Outcry: The escalating violence and apparent inability of local authorities to protect the Osage drew national attention, leading to federal involvement.
The FBI's Involvement
Hoover White
- A Young J. Edgar Hoover: The case fell under the jurisdiction of the then-nascent Bureau of Investigation, led by a young J. Edgar Hoover.
- The Undercover Operation: Hoover appointed a former Texas Ranger, Tom White, to lead an undercover investigation, employing a team of agents who posed as ranchers, insurance salesmen, and other locals.
Uncovering the Conspiracy
- The Mastermind – William K. Hale: The investigation revealed a chilling conspiracy led by William K. Hale, a powerful local figure, who orchestrated the murders to gain control of the Osage headrights.
- The Trial and Convictions: The case led to several convictions, including that of Hale, marking a significant success for the FBI.
Impact and Legacy
- The Birth of the Modern FBI: The Osage murders investigation is credited with helping to establish the FBI's reputation for professional law enforcement and advanced investigative techniques.
- Continued Injustice: Despite the convictions, many of the murders remained unsolved, and the broader exploitation and mistreatment of the Osage Nation continued.
Conclusion
The Osage Murders serve as a stark reminder of a period of exploitation and injustice against Native Americans, a narrative intertwined with the transformation of American law enforcement. It underscores the necessity of acknowledging and learning from the darker aspects of history. It's a story of tragedy, resilience, and the quest for justice, demonstrating the need for ethical and competent investigative bodies.
As Always, Thanks For Reading
Rick
_________________________________________________________________